Photo Quality Verses Votes

OptiximaOptixima ✭✭
edited December 2020 in Ingress Community Feedback

I play both Ingress and Pokemon Go. A lot of the Go community asked me about several POI's in our very small town that now have photos that are so dark or off-centered, that you can't even tell what they are anymore when sending gifts to people (as the image of the POI goes with the gifts they exchange).

I went and took new photos, being sure to center the object of the POI itself, and to make sure it is bright enough to see. However, the person who uploaded the dark images, suddenly got two more votes. I called in two of the only other players I know in our town and we voted the bright image back up. And then the dark image had another 2 votes.

First, this appears to be an alt account issue because we don't have that many players in our little town. We don't even get that many coming through. Also, I can't imagine any player choosing off-centered dark images over brighter clearer/sharper images. And thirdly, this isn't a faction war as we are the same faction.

This player has done the same to other POI's now where their replacement images really are worse than the originals he/she replaced and yet manage to get 7 to 10 votes in a town with maybe 4 players.

1) Is this a reportable offense without proof?

2) Wasn't there talk of a broader and more legitimate voting procedure coming?

As an example - the POI pictured is "THE CANNON". You can see the subject clearly in the original (top) and middle image. But the bottom one keeps getting voted up.

I have other examples like this

PLEASE tell me there WILL be a better way coming! Maybe only those level 8 and higher can vote? Maybe a Wayfarer like voting procedure?

Post edited by Optixima on

Comments

  • OptiximaOptixima ✭✭
    edited December 2020

    Here is another - the subject is the wooden statue. But in the newest one (far right) it is just a fraction of the image and almost indiscernible and yet it miraculously showed up with 8 votes.

    I really hope Niantic can come up with a better voting procedure like Wayfarer or no player under level 8 can vote.


  • I think this is a symptom of one of my biggest gripes in this game. The person probably snapped the photo from their car, because we know it's just too hard to get out and walk.🙄

    When someone takes the time to nominate a thoughtful portal that is of something artistic or historical, rather than some stupid sign, you'd think that the photo should help express it's value.

    I agree with Landrocketess

  • MoogModularMoogModular ✭✭✭✭✭

    The simpler way is just to have the photos rotate every x days instead of showing just the top voted photos. Maybe just remove the voting altogether as this problem existed before Go.

  • OptiximaOptixima ✭✭
    edited December 2020

    Yes, it appears that while we are walking up to take images, this person is not. The newest bad image this week was clearly taken while he was sitting in a coffee hut drive-thru. At least based on where the camera was when it was taken and it would explain the terrible angle.


    Does anyone know if Niantic plans on ever letting REAL people vote online like in Wayfarer?

Sign In or Register to comment.